Wednesday, June 25, 2014

Well, that didn't work too well.

I haven't managed any painting yet, looks like I need a casting session first but I did get 3 more units onto their bases. I have also had time for a little 1 or 2 on 1 rule tests. It did not take long to realize I was nowhere near the mark.

The problems started with me trying to arrange the rules to handle my new bases which are 1 rank deep although I still want to deploy them 2 figures deep in line, and my  1/72 ACW bases which are based 2 deep. Eventually I decided to call my new bases "1/2 bases", treating 2 of them as a single 2x2, 6 figure stand but capable of more photogenic posing when required. Sort of like these 1 piece bases from a 2012 photo.



But that was just the start. The proposed changes violated so many principles and aims that I have laid out over the last few years that I just ditched them and started looking over old posts and backing up a few years. The result has become very similar to what was used in the above game and the Cobbs Farm game seen below.



A working draft is published for those with time to waste  but a proper test is a week away, there is lots of proof reading to be done and I'm finally ready after 5 years to start putting  back in all the odd bits, special troops and rules and so on for the Atlantica campaign rather than just leaving the door open. I don't remember seeing the chance cards now that I think of it so I'll have to port them over.

6 comments:

  1. Ross, I know what you mean about two ranks. Single-ranked foot don't look right to me as representative of a "line unit" . . . it might be okay for skirmishers, but not for formed foot units.


    -- Jeff

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I agree Jeff though the depth sometimes bothers me with big figures. The real problem is when one gets into the period where sometimes the fighting is done I close order but sometimes all the fighting is done with 1/2 or more of the unit deployed as skirmishers.

      Delete
  2. Archduke Piccolo has left a new comment on your post "Well, that didn't work too well.":

    H'mmm.... Food for thought, there. I'll be publishing my account of Elchingen in a day or two. You will find that exercise was not without its problematics, either. Cheers,
    Ion

    ReplyDelete
  3. I never fail to enjoy reading your trials and experiments Ross.

    ReplyDelete