There seems to be a fairly wide consensus that gridded games work best when units are indivisible and there is a 1:1 relationship between grid areas and units. The existing 4 figure Square Brigadier units felt OK with units as battalions for Division sized battles or, for the 20th C or Colonial skirmish games, as companies. When it comes to low level actions between mid to late 19th century armies, a battalion can occupy as small an area as 50 yards wide and 10 yards deep in mass or up to under 500 yards wide and 500 yards deep if deployed as skirmishers and supports. More than that, it was fairly common, especially in a small force, to detach companies for specific tasks, such as to clear a wood to the flank.
Oberhilse's American Legion deployed for battle occupying 4 squares. (oops too many men in the skirmish line!) |
Since command control ranges would remain tight, widespread skirmishers would become hard to control while masses would be vulnerable and a poor use of resources in the front line as only front rank stands can fire. They would be handy for reserves in dead ground though and an in between formation would be good for assaults since they could withstand some hits. Morale for the battalion would be based on over all losses.
Still working on the details. I have till Saturday morning......
Ross your boundless enthusiasm is great,you keep striving and experimenting.You are an inspiration to us. Keep working towards your ideal game and inspiring us to try and do the same.
ReplyDeleteOnce again a stimulating post with good reasons for change and something for me to think about on the way to work today.I think the stand idea has much to commend it and i look forward to seeing the companies in action...
Alan
Slight hitch when I counted how many grid squares I'd need for the number of companies this addds up to, but I'm still swinging.
DeleteSlight hitch when I counted how many grid squares I'd need for the number of companies this addds up to, but I'm still swinging.
DeleteNever used grids, but always felt (Ancients influence?) that the problem is that they're square - most units tend to be linear. Have thought about the option of 'quarter grids', so that a 'unit' covers 2 grid frontages rather than 1, but still only 1 grid deep.
ReplyDeleteIn earlier periods that is true but even in the 18th C one had to leave deployment room behind units and room for caissons for artillery. Later one gets the distance between skirmish line and supports. Still I have thought about a multi square solution.
Delete